Choosing between Nationwide and Allstate can be challenging, as both are well-established insurance providers with a broad range of coverage options. While Nationwide is known for its competitive pricing and strong customer satisfaction, Allstate offers extensive customization options and a robust network of local agents.
This detailed comparison will help you determine which insurer is best suited for your auto, home, or bundled insurance needs based on coverage options, pricing, claims process, customer service, unique features, availability, and reputation.
Share This
Customer Reviews
START FREE ONLINE QUOTE NOW
At Blake Insurance Group, we respect your privacy. Your personal information is used solely for quote purposes and is not shared or sold
Coverage Options
Both Nationwide and Allstate offer standard auto, home, renters, and specialty insurance policies, but they differ in additional coverage options.
Nationwide Coverage Options
- Auto Insurance: Liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist, medical payments
- SmartRide® Telematics Program: Rewards drivers for safe driving
- SmartMiles® Pay-Per-Mile Insurance: Ideal for low-mileage drivers
- Gap Insurance: Covers the difference between a car’s value and the loan balance if totaled
- Homeowners Insurance: Covers dwelling, liability, personal property, and optional add-ons like better roof replacement and water backup protection
- Umbrella Insurance: Provides additional liability protection beyond standard policies
Allstate Coverage Options
- Auto Insurance: Liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist
- Drivewise® Telematics Program: Monitors driving habits for discounts
- Accident Forgiveness: Prevents premium increases after a first accident
- Deductible Rewards®: Lowers deductibles for safe driving
- New Car Replacement: Pays to replace a totaled car with a brand-new one
- Homeowners Insurance: Covers dwelling, liability, and additional protection for high-value homes
Key Takeaway: Nationwide is ideal for low-mileage drivers and those looking for telematics-based savings, while Allstate offers more extensive policy customization and accident-related benefits.
Pricing and Discounts
Insurance rates depend on factors such as location, driving history, credit score, and coverage selections. Nationwide generally offers lower base rates, while Allstate provides better rewards for long-term policyholders.
Nationwide Pricing & Discounts
- SmartRide® Telematics Discount – Rewards safe driving habits
- SmartMiles® Discount – Best for drivers who don’t drive frequently
- Multi-policy and multi-vehicle discounts
- Good student and defensive driving discounts
- Accident-free and anti-theft device discounts
Allstate Pricing & Discounts
- Drivewise® Telematics Discount – Personalized savings based on driving behavior
- Multi-policy and multi-vehicle discounts
- Safe driving bonus rewards
- Accident Forgiveness to avoid premium increases
- New Car Discount for recently purchased vehicles
Key Takeaway: Nationwide offers lower rates for low-mileage drivers, while Allstate provides better incentives for long-term policyholders.
Claims Process
The claims process is an essential factor when choosing an insurance provider. Both Nationwide and Allstate offer 24/7 claims support, but their approaches differ.
Nationwide Claims Process
- 24/7 claims filing via phone, online, or mobile app
- On Your Side® Review for personalized policy check-ups
- Vanishing Deductible rewards for safe drivers
Allstate Claims Process
- 24/7 claims support with online tracking tools
- Claim Satisfaction Guarantee: Refunds part of your premium if unsatisfied with a claim
- Allstate Good Hands Repair Network: Partners with repair shops for faster service
Key Takeaway: Allstate has an edge with its Claim Satisfaction Guarantee, while Nationwide offers a more personalized policy review service.
Customer Service
Nationwide Customer Service
- Highly rated for agent availability and policy support
- Strong network of local agents across the U.S.
- Online and mobile policy management available
Allstate Customer Service
- Well-established network of local agents for in-person support
- Highly rated for digital tools and mobile claims tracking
- Mixed reviews for claims satisfaction
Key Takeaway: Both companies have strong agent networks, but Nationwide is better for personalized policy reviews, while Allstate excels in digital tools.
Unique Features
Nationwide Unique Features
- SmartMiles® – Ideal for policyholders who drive less
- Better Roof Replacement – Provides upgraded materials if your roof is damaged
- Vanishing Deductible – Lowers deductibles over time for safe drivers
Allstate Unique Features
- Drivewise® – Tracks driving behavior for potential savings
- Claim Satisfaction Guarantee – Refunds part of your premium if unhappy with a claim
- New Car Replacement – Replaces totaled vehicles with a brand-new car
Key Takeaway: Nationwide offers better perks for safe and low-mileage drivers, while Allstate provides stronger claims-related benefits and new car replacement coverage.
Availability
- Nationwide: Available nationwide, but discounts vary by state.
- Allstate: Available nationwide, with strong agent availability in most regions.
Key Takeaway: Both insurers offer nationwide coverage, but Allstate has a larger local agent network.
Reputation and Reviews
Both Nationwide and Allstate have strong financial stability and industry reputation, but they differ in customer satisfaction and claims handling.
Nationwide Reputation
- A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best for financial strength
- Highly rated for personalized policy management
- Mixed reviews on digital claims processing
Allstate Reputation
- A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best for financial strength
- Highly rated for digital tools and policy customization
- Mixed customer satisfaction for claims handling
Key Takeaway: Nationwide is praised for agent support and policy personalization, while Allstate is known for its digital tools and accident forgiveness perks.
Final Verdict: Which One is Better?
The best insurance provider between Nationwide and Allstate depends on your budget, service preferences, and coverage needs.
Choose Nationwide if:
✔️ You are a low-mileage driver looking for SmartMiles® pay-per-mile insurance
✔️ You want safe driver rewards and vanishing deductibles
✔️ You prefer working with a strong local agent network for policy management
Choose Allstate if:
✔️ You want customizable policies with accident forgiveness benefits
✔️ You prefer digital tools for policy management and claims tracking
✔️ You are a new car owner looking for replacement coverage
Both Nationwide and Allstate offer strong financial backing and comprehensive insurance products, but Nationwide is better for safe and low-mileage drivers, while Allstate provides better accident forgiveness and digital claims management.
Still unsure which is right for you? Contact Blake Insurance Group today for a personalized quote and expert advice! 🚗🏡
Nationwide vs. Allstate - Frequently Asked Questions
Nationwide generally offers lower base auto insurance rates compared to Allstate. Nationwide’s average monthly premium is around $120, while Allstate’s average is $160. However, Allstate offers better accident forgiveness and safe driving rewards.
Nationwide is highly rated for personalized policy management and customer service, while Allstate receives strong ratings for digital tools and online claims tracking. However, Allstate has mixed reviews regarding claims resolution speed.
Both Nationwide and Allstate offer bundling discounts, but Nationwide's bundling discount can reach up to 20%, making it a better option for customers looking to save on multiple policies.
Nationwide tends to offer more competitive rates for high-risk drivers, including those with DUIs, accidents, or poor credit, whereas Allstate has stricter underwriting policies that can result in higher premiums for high-risk drivers.
Nationwide’s average homeowners insurance rate is around $1,236 per year, while Allstate’s average is $1,414 per year. Nationwide’s home insurance policies are slightly more affordable, but Allstate provides more customizable coverage options.
Both companies are financially stable:
✔ Nationwide holds an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best.
✔ Allstate holds an A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best.
Both insurers are financially strong and capable of handling claims efficiently.
Nationwide is highly rated for its agent network and personalized customer service, while Allstate is well known for digital tools and mobile claims tracking.
✔ Choose Nationwide if you prefer strong agent support and a personalized policy review service.
✔ Choose Allstate if you prefer self-service digital tools and accident forgiveness benefits.
Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed