Ten Auto Insurance Companies in Arizona — Compare Rates, Discounts & Coverage
Shopping for car insurance in the Grand Canyon State? This guide highlights ten widely available auto insurance companies in Arizona and what each is generally known for, so you can compare options side by side. Because pricing varies by driver profile, vehicle, and ZIP code, the most effective way to find a lower rate is to compare multiple carriers at once. Blake Insurance Group is an independent agency—we’ll help you review coverages and discounts, explain contract and lender requirements, and provide same-day proof of insurance when you bind.
Arizona Top-10 auto insurance snapshot
The table below lists ten carriers many Arizona drivers consider. Notes are general and not guarantees— programs, discounts, and availability can vary. Use this list to build a shortlist, then run real quotes with your details for accurate pricing.
| Company | Often Considered By | Potential Highlights | Good To Know |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | Households bundling auto + home | Local agent network; broad discount set | Telematics option may reward safe driving |
| GEICO | Price-focused shoppers | Strong online experience; convenient ID cards | Check bundling and vehicle-safety discounts |
| Progressive | Drivers wanting usage/telematics | Snapshot® telematics; flexible coverage add-ons | Compare rental & glass options for AZ highways |
| Allstate | Families & homeowners | Drivewise® telematics; accident forgiveness options | Ask about bundling and safe-driving rewards |
| USAA | Military members & families (eligibility required) | Member-focused service; broad product suite | Eligibility rules apply—ask if you qualify |
| Farmers | Drivers who prefer agent guidance | Many endorsements; claims support | Ask about OEM parts and roadside options |
| American Family | Bundlers and smart-home users | Device/protective discounts; agent support | Check home-auto package savings |
| Nationwide | Drivers exploring telematics | SmartRide® program; good-student discounts | Compare glass coverage & rental tiers |
| Liberty Mutual | Customizable policies | Accident forgiveness options; online tools | Review roadside and new-car replacement |
| Travelers | Commuters & frequent highway users | Bundle potential; robust coverage options | Consider higher UM/UIM on busy corridors |
How to compare quotes (the smart way)
Match apples to apples
Use the same liability limits, comp/collision deductibles, and add-ons (like roadside or rental) across every quote. Small changes can swing price—keep coverage settings consistent to see genuine differences.
Decide your glass gameplan
Arizona highways are tough on windshields. Consider full glass or lower comp deductibles if you rack up freeway miles on I-10, US-60, 101, or 202.
Bundle strategically
Bundling auto with home, condo, or renters can stabilize pricing. Ask us to check packages across multiple carriers—not every bundle saves the same.
Use telematics if you drive safely
Usage-based programs may reward smooth braking, daytime driving, and fewer miles. If you’re a cautious driver, it’s worth a look.
What affects auto insurance rates in Arizona
- Where you garage: Urban corridors can see more claims and theft than rural ZIPs.
- Vehicle & usage: High-value vehicles, long commutes, and business use typically cost more.
- Driving history: Tickets, accidents, and DUI/SR-22 filings influence pricing and eligibility.
- Coverage settings: Higher liability/UM-UIM and lower deductibles increase premium but improve protection.
- Discount fit: Bundles, telematics, homeowner status, good-student, and safety devices can help.
Discounts & ways to save (without underinsuring)
- Bundle auto + home/renters: Packages often unlock the best overall value.
- Telematics: Safe drivers may see savings—ask us to estimate typical ranges before enrolling.
- Glass strategy: Windshield claims are common; picking the right comp deductible avoids nickel-and-dime frustrations.
- Teen drivers: Good-student, driver training, and vehicle choice matter. Telematics can help establish a lower-risk pattern.
- Policy hygiene: Keep mailing, lender, and garaging info current; lapses can spike rates.
Coverage choices (liability vs “full coverage”)
Arizona requires liability insurance; many drivers also select “full coverage,” which generally means liability plus comprehensive and collision. If a lender holds your title, comp/collision is usually required. We’ll help you choose limits that fit your risk tolerance, often aiming well above bare minimums for better financial protection—especially if you drive frequently, have youthful operators, or own assets.
FAQs
Who is the cheapest auto insurance company in Arizona?
No single company is always cheapest. Prices change by driver, vehicle, ZIP, and discounts. Run multiple quotes with identical coverages to see the true winner for your profile.
Do I need full coverage if my car is paid off?
Not legally, but comprehensive and collision can still make sense if repair or replacement would strain your budget—especially given Arizona’s windshield risks.
Can I get same-day proof of insurance?
Often yes. Once you select a quote and bind, we can provide ID cards and help with lender or registration documents.
How many quotes should I compare?
Three to five is a good start. Our widget and team compare multiple carriers at once so you don’t repeat your info everywhere.
Will a telematics program raise my rate?
Programs vary. Many are designed to reward safe driving; we’ll explain pros and cons so you choose with eyes open.
Disclosure & trademarks
Coverage, discounts, program names, and availability vary by insurer and Arizona location. This page provides general information and does not modify policy terms or constitute a binder. All third-party trademarks (e.g., State Farm®, GEICO®, Progressive®, Allstate®, USAA®, Farmers®, American Family®, Nationwide®, Liberty Mutual®, Travelers®) are property of their respective owners and appear for identification and comparative purposes only. Blake Insurance Group: Licensed insurance producer (NPR/NPN 16944666).
Share This
Customer Reviews
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: info@blakeinsurancegroup.com
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed
Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent