Humana and Cigna are two major players in the U.S. health insurance market, each with distinct strengths and market focuses. As of 2025, these companies continue to compete for market share and customer loyalty while exploring potential merger opportunities.
Cigna, founded in 1792, has grown to become one of the largest global health insurance providers, with a network of approximately 1.7 million healthcare professionals worldwide. Humana, established in 1961, is a major player in the Medicare Advantage market and has been expanding its focus on government-sponsored health programs.
Schedule with Blake
Expert insurance advice in your community
- ✓ Get a free no-obligation quote
- ✓ Review existing policy
- ✓ Ask any insurance questions
Customer Reviews
Share This
Both companies offer a range of health insurance products, including Medicare Advantage plans, prescription drug plans, and commercial insurance. However, they differ in their geographic coverage, network sizes, and specific plan offerings. Cigna has a larger global presence and a more extensive provider network, while Humana has a stronger foothold in the Medicare Advantage market, particularly in the United States.
As these two insurance giants continue to evolve in the ever-changing healthcare landscape, their potential merger talks have sparked interest in the industry, raising questions about market competition, regulatory challenges, and the future of healthcare coverage for millions of Americans.
Plan Options & Coverage Types
HMO, PPO, POS, EPO Differences
- Humana: Offers a wide variety of HMO, PPO, POS, and EPO plans nationwide, providing extensive flexibility, especially strong in Medicare Advantage.
- Cigna: Provides primarily PPO and HMO plans, known for broader PPO networks and flexibility, especially for employer-sponsored plans and individual marketplace offerings.
Individual Plans vs. Employer-Sponsored Plans
- Humana: Prominent in both individual ACA marketplace and employer-sponsored group plans. Particularly strong in Medicare Advantage individual market.
- Cigna: Strong emphasis on employer-sponsored health plans and individual ACA marketplace plans, typically appealing to businesses and self-employed individuals due to wide network flexibility.
Medicare Advantage vs. Medicare Supplement
- Humana: Nationally recognized leader in Medicare Advantage, offering extensive supplemental benefits like dental, vision, hearing, and highly competitive Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans.
- Cigna: Offers robust Medicare Advantage options and quality Medigap coverage, though with a narrower market presence compared to Humana. Known for personalized Medicare Advantage care management.
Medicaid and ACA Marketplace Options
- Humana: Limited participation in Medicaid, moderate presence in ACA marketplaces, predominantly focused on Medicare and employer-sponsored coverage.
- Cigna: Minimal participation in Medicaid; broader ACA marketplace presence in select states, catering primarily to individual consumers and small businesses.
Cost & Affordability
Monthly Premiums Comparison
- Humana: Competitive premiums with considerable affordability in Medicare Advantage and individual plans, slightly higher premiums for broader network PPO plans.
- Cigna: Typically moderate to higher premiums, reflecting extensive PPO networks and provider flexibility, particularly appealing for businesses or individuals needing national coverage.
Deductibles and Copayments
- Humana: Offers a wide range of deductibles and copay options, typically lower for HMO options and Medicare Advantage plans, higher for PPO flexibility.
- Cigna: Moderate deductibles, typically higher copayments, emphasizing straightforward cost structures particularly favored by employer-sponsored plan members.
Out-of-pocket Maximums
- Humana: Offers moderate to lower out-of-pocket maximums, especially attractive within HMO or Medicare Advantage plans.
- Cigna: Generally moderate out-of-pocket maximums, slightly higher reflecting extensive provider choice within PPO structures.
Pricing Transparency
- Humana: Clear and detailed pricing transparency, user-friendly tools for understanding cost-sharing, particularly strong digital support for Medicare members.
- Cigna: Excellent pricing transparency with user-friendly online comparison tools, though more geared towards employer groups and self-funded arrangements.
Network Size & Provider Accessibility
Size and Geographic Reach of Provider Networks
- Humana: Extensive nationwide networks, especially strong in Medicare Advantage markets. Broad national PPO access beneficial for members who travel.
- Cigna: Large nationwide provider network with substantial international coverage, ideal for employer-sponsored plans with geographically dispersed employees.
Specialist Access and Referrals
- Humana: PPO and EPO plans offer direct specialist access without referrals; HMO plans require PCP referrals.
- Cigna: PPO plans typically allow direct specialist visits without referrals, with referrals required mainly within HMO structures.
Availability of In-network Hospitals and Doctors
- Humana: Broadly available network with numerous top-rated hospitals and healthcare providers nationwide, particularly strong in Medicare Advantage.
- Cigna: Extensive network presence nationwide, particularly appealing for large employer groups needing expansive in-network access.
Out-of-network Coverage and Reimbursement Rates
- Humana: Generous out-of-network coverage primarily through PPO/POS plans, with above-average reimbursement rates.
- Cigna: Strong out-of-network coverage in PPO/POS plans with generally favorable reimbursement rates, appealing to users needing maximum flexibility.
Member Benefits & Perks
Wellness Incentives (Fitness Memberships, Preventive Screenings)
- Humana: Renowned wellness incentives through Go365® program, gym memberships, health coaching, preventive screenings, and rewards for healthy behaviors.
- Cigna: Comprehensive wellness programs offering fitness discounts, preventive care screenings, health coaching, and incentives through wellness apps and employer-sponsored programs.
Chronic Disease Management Programs
- Humana: Robust chronic disease management with personalized coaching, remote monitoring, strong Medicare chronic care offerings, and condition-specific management programs.
- Cigna: Excellent chronic disease management programs, including comprehensive support for diabetes, heart disease, and asthma, with personalized coaching and employer wellness integration.
Telehealth and Virtual Care Offerings
- Humana: Strong virtual care options via partnership with MDLIVE, providing easy access to telehealth consultations, including behavioral health.
- Cigna: Offers robust telehealth through MDLIVE partnership as well, providing seamless digital access for general medicine and mental health services.
Mental Health Coverage and Services
- Humana: Comprehensive mental health coverage including wide provider networks, virtual counseling, and integrated behavioral health resources.
- Cigna: Exceptional mental health support, particularly strong in behavioral health integration, extensive network of providers, and accessible virtual therapy.
Customer Service & Member Experience
Customer Satisfaction Ratings (J.D. Power, NCQA)
- Humana: Consistently receives high marks, especially among Medicare Advantage customers; highly praised for service responsiveness and ease of plan management.
- Cigna: Generally strong satisfaction scores, particularly noted for proactive wellness programs and effective employer-sponsored plan management, though occasionally trailing Humana in Medicare customer ratings.
Ease of Claims Processing and Disputes
- Humana: Recognized for streamlined claims processing, few disputes, and efficient resolution mechanisms.
- Cigna: Known for efficient claims handling, but some employer-sponsored plans experience occasional claims complexity, particularly around self-funded arrangements.
Quality and Usability of Online Portals/Apps
- Humana: Highly-rated digital platforms, intuitive mobile app, easy claims management, and telehealth integration.
- Cigna: Excellent digital experience, comprehensive portals, user-friendly mobile app particularly strong in wellness resources, claims management, and telehealth support.
Reputation & Financial Stability
Financial Strength Ratings (A.M. Best, Moody’s, S&P)
- Humana: Exceptional financial strength ratings (“A-” or higher), reflecting longstanding market presence and consistent performance.
- Cigna: Strong financial stability ratings (“A” range from agencies like A.M. Best and Moody’s), reflecting reliable operations and stable long-term outlook.
Company Reputation and Market History
- Humana: Established reputation (founded 1961), widely recognized leader particularly in Medicare Advantage, trusted for comprehensive coverage and member-centric services.
- Cigna: Longstanding global insurer (founded 1792), respected for international and employer-focused coverage, known for robust wellness and innovative care management programs.
Consumer Complaints and Regulatory Issues
- Humana: Consistently low complaint rates, favorable regulatory reviews, and minimal issues related to claims or customer service.
- Cigna: Generally low complaint ratio, though occasional disputes arise around claims processing, particularly related to self-funded employer plans.
Medicare-specific Criteria
- Humana: Industry leader in Medicare Advantage, consistently high Medicare Star Ratings (often 4+ stars), comprehensive extra benefits (dental, vision, hearing), widely available Medigap plans, favorable cost-sharing structures.
- Cigna: Good Medicare Advantage offerings with personalized chronic care management, moderately rated (3-4 stars), fewer supplemental benefits than Humana, though solid Medigap offerings.
Employer & Small-Business Focus
- Humana: Strong small-business and employer coverage options, fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded solutions, robust employee wellness incentives, and customizable plan structures.
- Cigna: Leading provider in employer-sponsored and international plans, excellent customization, and flexibility for fully insured and self-funded arrangements, extensive wellness programs highly appealing to employers.
FAQs: Humana vs. Cigna Health Insurance
Which company offers more flexible health insurance plan types, Humana or Cigna?
Both Humana and Cigna offer multiple plan options, including HMO and PPO. Humana provides extensive Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans, while Cigna is especially known for strong employer-sponsored PPO plans with nationwide provider flexibility.
Does Humana or Cigna have better Medicare Advantage plans?
Humana consistently ranks higher in Medicare Advantage offerings, often achieving higher Medicare Star Ratings (4+ stars) and more comprehensive additional benefits like dental, vision, and hearing. Cigna offers quality Medicare Advantage plans, often noted for personalized chronic care support but with slightly fewer supplemental benefits.
Which health insurance provider is more affordable, Humana or Cigna?
Humana typically provides more affordable premiums, particularly with HMO and Medicare Advantage plans. Cigna's premiums can be moderately higher but reflect broader network flexibility, particularly valuable for employer-sponsored plans.
Do Humana and Cigna offer telehealth services?
Yes, both Humana and Cigna offer robust telehealth services, including virtual doctor visits and behavioral health support through their partnerships with telehealth providers like MDLIVE.
Which insurance company has better customer satisfaction, Humana or Cigna?
Humana often scores slightly higher in customer satisfaction, particularly among Medicare Advantage members. Cigna also has strong customer satisfaction scores, especially praised for employer-sponsored plans and proactive wellness initiatives.
How do the provider networks of Humana and Cigna compare?
Both insurers have extensive networks nationwide. Humana's network is particularly strong for Medicare Advantage and individual plans, whereas Cigna offers broad PPO networks ideal for employer-sponsored and geographically dispersed coverage.
Are Humana or Cigna plans better suited for small businesses?
Both companies cater effectively to small businesses. Humana offers flexible group plans, wellness incentives, and multiple funding options. Cigna is particularly strong in fully insured and self-funded employer plans, known for wellness integration and customization.
Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed