Check Your Local Rates Now

Renters insurance is a vital safeguard for tenants, offering protection for personal belongings, liability, and additional living expenses. In 2025, ePremium and Assurant are two leading providers, each with distinct advantages and drawbacks. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which is the better fit for your needs.

Overview and Company Background

ePremium
ePremium specializes in renters insurance for multifamily and single-family rentals, partnering with property managers and landlords to provide integrated solutions. The company is known for streamlined enrollment and unique coverage options, often required or recommended by property managers.

Assurant
Assurant is a national insurer offering renters insurance directly to consumers and through property management partners. The company is recognized for its broad standard coverage, customizable policies, and a strong digital presence, making it accessible to renters across the country.

Coverage Options

Both providers offer robust standard coverage, but Assurant stands out for including mold damage and offering replacement cost as standard. ePremium’s unique features include bedbug and pet damage coverage in most policies.

Optional Add-ons and Endorsements

ePremium:

• Identity theft protection

• Water/sewer backup

• Earthquake (CA only)

• Biohazard cleanup

• Resident-caused water damage

• Scheduled personal property

Assurant:

• Earthquake coverage (select states)

• Flood insurance

• Pet damage protection

• Sewer backup

• Smartphone/device protection

• Identity fraud expense

• Unemployment insurance (rent protection)

Assurant offers a wider variety of optional add-ons, including unique options such as unemployment insurance and smartphone protection.

Pricing and Discounts

Assurant is generally more affordable and transparent about pricing, while ePremium’s rates can be higher and discounts depend on the underlying carrier.

Availability

• ePremium: Available in all 50 states and D.C., but only through participating property managers and landlords.

• Assurant: Available nationwide to all renters, regardless of landlord participation.

Claims Process and Customer Experience

ePremium:
Claims are managed by the underlying carrier. Some customers report delays and communication issues, particularly with claim payouts and support.

Assurant:
Claims can be filed online or by phone 24/7. Many customers experience fast claims turnaround, but the company receives more complaints than average, mostly about claim denials and customer service.

Customer Satisfaction and Complaints

ePremium:
Receives mixed reviews, with praise for easy enrollment and unique coverage, but criticism for higher costs and limited customization. Common complaints involve claims delays and communication breakdowns.

Assurant:
Generally receives positive feedback for coverage and value, but also sees a higher volume of complaints, particularly about claims handling and customer service responsiveness. The lack of a mobile app is a noted inconvenience for some customers.

Pros and Cons

Who Should Choose Which?

• Choose ePremium if:

  • Your property manager requires or recommends it.

  • You want built-in bedbug and pet damage protection.

  • You need a security deposit alternative.

• Choose Assurant if:

  • You want more flexible coverage and add-ons.

  • You value affordable, transparent pricing.

  • You want to add roommates or pets easily.

  • You prefer direct-to-consumer service and online management.

Comparison Table

Conclusion

Both ePremium and Assurant offer strong renters insurance options for 2025, but they cater to different needs. ePremium is ideal for renters in property-managed communities seeking unique protections like bedbug and pet damage coverage, especially if a security deposit alternative is appealing.

Assurant is better suited for renters who want affordable, flexible coverage with a wide range of add-ons and the convenience of direct online management. Consider your property’s requirements, desired coverage features, and customer service expectations before making your decision.