National Life Group vs EquiTrust

For clients seeking affordable life insurance, National Life Group and EquiTrust are two established insurers with contrasting strengths. National Life Group is known for its comprehensive policy suite and top-tier financial ratings, while EquiTrust is recognized for innovative annuity and permanent life solutions. Here’s how they compare for value-focused shoppers.

Life Insurance Calculator

Life Insurance Calculator

Life Insurance Quote

Life Insurance Quote

Select a provider and get an instant quote online.

Get Quote
Google Reviews Widget

Customer Reviews

Loading reviews...

Company Overviews

National Life Group
Founded in 1848 in Vermont, National Life Group is one of the oldest mutual life insurers in the U.S. It serves over 1.2 million customers nationwide and is recognized as a leader in indexed universal life insurance and employer-sponsored coverage for educators. The company emphasizes service, community involvement, and a mission-driven culture.

EquiTrust
Established in 1996 and headquartered in Chicago, EquiTrust is a national carrier specializing in annuities and permanent life insurance. The company is noted for its client-friendly products and innovation, including unique index-linked annuities and single-premium life policies. Magic Johnson Enterprises has held a controlling interest since 2015.

National Life Group vs EquiTrust Life Insurance Comparison

Financial Strength & Ratings

Company AM Best S&P Fitch Notes
National Life Group A+ (Superior) A+ (Strong) Top-tier, stable outlook
EquiTrust B++ (Good) A- (Strong) A- (Strong) Solid, but below many peers

National Life Group enjoys superior ratings and a long record of financial strength. EquiTrust is stable but rated lower, which may matter to risk-averse buyers.

Policy Types Offered

Policy Type National Life Group EquiTrust
Term Life Yes (10–30 years, convertible) No
Whole Life Yes (flexible, dividend-paying) Yes (single premium, interest-sensitive)
Universal Life Yes (fixed and indexed) No
Indexed Universal Life Yes (multiple IULs) No
Final Expense No standalone, but small face amounts possible No
Annuities Yes (various types) Yes (diverse, index-linked)

Coverage Options & Flexibility

National Life Group:

  • Term coverage from 10 to 30 years, convertible to permanent policies
  • Whole life and universal life with flexible premiums and cash value
  • Indexed universal life with living benefits and cash accumulation
  • Many policies include or offer living benefits for terminal, chronic, or critical illness

EquiTrust:

  • Permanent life options are single-premium or fixed premium, often tied to market index performance
  • WealthMax Bonus Life and WealthSure Life are single-premium policies with bonuses and interest-linked growth
  • No term life; focus is on wealth transfer, estate planning, and annuity-linked solutions

Underwriting & Application Process

National Life Group: Offers traditional and accelerated underwriting. No-medical-exam options for select policies and amounts. Application is agent-assisted, with some digital tools but not fully online.

EquiTrust: Underwriting varies by product. Some policies use simplified or digital underwriting. Bridge® annuity with LTC rider uses a digital video call for underwriting with three classes: Preferred, Standard, Secure.

Pricing & Affordability

National Life Group: Competitive, especially for indexed universal life and term policies. Term life is often affordable for healthy applicants, with level premiums and conversion options.

EquiTrust: Focuses on single-premium and permanent life, cost-effective for lump-sum buyers but less accessible for those seeking low monthly premiums. No term life, so not ideal for lowest-cost, high-face-amount protection.

Alternatives to Consider

  • Mutual of Omaha: Affordable term and whole life.
  • Banner Life, Protective, Pacific Life: Strong for term life and competitive rates.
  • Penn Mutual, Guardian, MassMutual: For high-dividend whole life.
  • Corebridge, Ladder, Haven Life: For digital-first, low-cost term life.

Riders & Customization

Rider/Feature National Life Group EquiTrust
Accelerated Benefits (Living) Yes (terminal, chronic, critical) Yes (terminal illness, nursing home waivers)
Waiver of Premium Yes Not standard
Children’s Term Rider Yes Not available
Guaranteed Insurability Yes Not available
Paid-Up Additions Yes (whole life) No
Long-Term Care Rider No (LTC not standard) Yes (with Bridge® annuity)
Premium Bonuses No Yes (up to 12% on WealthMax Bonus Life)

National Life Group offers a wider array of riders for life insurance, while EquiTrust stands out for annuity and LTC-linked features.

Best For…

National Life Group:

  • Shoppers wanting affordable term or indexed universal life with living benefits
  • Families seeking flexible coverage, cash value, and strong financial ratings
  • Those who value agent guidance and a long-standing, mission-driven company

EquiTrust:

  • Buyers seeking single-premium, permanent life insurance for estate or wealth transfer
  • Clients interested in annuity-linked solutions, LTC riders, or index-linked growth
  • Those preferring to work with independent agents and considering lump-sum funding

Pros and Cons

Company Pros Cons
National Life Group Top financial ratings, broad product suite, living benefits, affordable term & IUL, strong agent network No standalone final expense, not fully online, agent required for most policies
EquiTrust Innovative permanent life and annuity products, strong annuity/LTC options, premium bonuses, digital underwriting for some products Lower financial ratings, no term life, limited riders, agent-only access

Customer Experience & Support

National Life Group: High customer satisfaction, community involvement, and philanthropic focus. Agent-driven service, with digital account access and online loan requests.

EquiTrust: Good BBB rating, recognized for financial stability, but not BBB accredited. Customer reviews are mixed; some note lack of transparency and online claims options. Products and service are only available through independent agents.

Final Verdict

National Life Group is the stronger choice for most clients seeking affordable, flexible life insurance—especially term or indexed universal life—with robust living benefits and top-tier financial strength.

EquiTrust is best suited for those looking for permanent, single-premium life insurance or innovative annuity solutions, but its lower financial ratings and lack of term life may be a drawback for budget-focused shoppers.

For pure affordability and breadth of options, National Life Group generally leads, while EquiTrust is a niche choice for estate planning and lump-sum buyers.

FAQs: National Life Group vs. EquiTrust Life Insurance

FAQs: National Life Group vs. EquiTrust Life Insurance

How do I file a death or living benefits claim with National Life Group? Visit the “Contact Claims” section at National Life Group’s website, email [email protected], or call 800-732-8939. You’ll need the policy number, insured’s name, and death or condition details.
What information is required to process a claim with National Life Group? Death claims require the policy number, insured's name, place and cause of death, and dates of birth and death. Living benefits require details of the condition and rider.
How long does it take National Life Group to process a claim? Death benefits: within 5 business days. Living benefits: within 15 business days after receiving all required documentation.
What could delay a claim with National Life Group? Possible delays: death abroad, accident/homicide, or within the 2-year contestability period.
Can I take a loan or withdrawal from a National Life Group policy? Yes, from permanent policies. Withdrawals/loans reduce the cash value and death benefit.
What types of life insurance and annuities does National Life Group offer? Term life, whole life, indexed universal life, and multiple annuity products.
What types of life insurance does EquiTrust offer? EquiTrust offers permanent life insurance, not term. Products include WealthMax, WealthHorizon, and annuities.
Does EquiTrust require a medical exam? Many policies do not require a medical exam, particularly single premium IULs.
How do I notify EquiTrust of a death or file a claim? Call EquiTrust at 888-400-5759 to start the claims process and get assistance.
Can the death benefit change over time with EquiTrust? Yes. It may decrease with loans or benefits paid, or increase with positive policy performance.
Does EquiTrust offer annuities? Yes. Products include fixed index, multi-year, fixed rate, and immediate annuities.
Are spousal continuations and joint ownership allowed with EquiTrust? Yes, for spouses. Spousal continuation is allowed if the spouse is the sole beneficiary.
Can I take a loan from my EquiTrust policy? Yes, if your policy allows it. Use the Life Policy Loan Request Form.
Does EquiTrust offer low-cost term insurance? No. EquiTrust only offers permanent life insurance.
How do I choose between National Life Group and EquiTrust? Choose National Life for strong ratings, broad offerings, and living benefits. Choose EquiTrust for single-premium, permanent options or annuities with fewer underwriting requirements.
Are both companies financially stable? National Life Group has A+ ratings. EquiTrust is rated B++ by AM Best and BBB+ by S&P—still good, but lower.

Blake Insurance Group

Phone: (888) 387-3687

Email: [email protected]

Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm

Sat-Sun: Closed

Author Box
Blake Nwosu

Blake Nwosu

Owner & Principal Agent

Expertise: All personal and commercial line insurance, including auto, home, business, health, and life insurance.

License: 16117464

Bio Page: https://blakeinsurancegroup.com/blake-nwosu/