MetLife Dental vs Guardian Dental
Choosing affordable dental insurance doesn’t have to be complicated. Two leading providers, MetLife Dental and Guardian Dental, offer competitive plans aimed at providing comprehensive dental care within budget. In this comparison, we’ll break down key features, costs, coverage options, and more, helping you find the ideal match for your dental needs and financial goals.
Dental Insurance Cost Calculator

Get Your Dental Insurance Quote
Protect your smile with comprehensive dental coverage. Get a personalized quote in minutes!
Start Your Free QuoteCoverage and Benefits:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife Dental plans provide extensive coverage, including preventive care such as routine exams, cleanings, and X-rays at little or no cost. Basic procedures (fillings, extractions) and major dental services (root canals, crowns, orthodontics) have varying coverage percentages, typically 50%-80%, depending on the chosen plan.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian Dental similarly covers preventive care fully and offers substantial coverage for basic and major procedures. Guardian notably provides flexible options for orthodontic treatments and implant coverage in certain plans, appealing to those seeking comprehensive care.
Network and Availability:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife offers a vast network, with access to more than 146,000 participating dental providers nationwide. This extensive network ensures members can conveniently find in-network care, reducing out-of-pocket expenses.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian maintains an extensive dental network as well, comprising over 120,000 dentists nationwide. While slightly smaller than MetLife, Guardian still provides broad access to quality care across many locations, ensuring convenience and affordability.
Cost Comparison:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife provides competitive monthly premiums generally ranging from $25 to $60, depending on the coverage level. Deductibles are typically between $50 and $100, with annual maximum benefits from $1,000 to $2,500, making it a budget-friendly choice for individuals and families.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian offers similarly attractive premiums, typically from $20 to $55 per month. Guardian often features higher annual maximums, ranging from $1,000 to $3,000, allowing greater financial flexibility for dental procedures. Deductibles usually align closely with industry standards, between $50 and $100.
Waiting Periods and Restrictions:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife typically has waiting periods for certain major services, often ranging from 6 to 12 months. However, preventive care generally has no waiting period, enabling immediate routine care coverage.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian Dental plans also commonly have waiting periods for major procedures, usually around 6 to 12 months. However, certain Guardian plans waive or reduce these waiting periods under specific conditions, providing quicker access to necessary dental treatments.
Ease of Use and Customer Service:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife provides intuitive online portals and mobile tools for easy management of your dental benefits, provider searches, and claims tracking. Their customer support is accessible and generally well-reviewed for efficiency and responsiveness.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian Dental also prioritizes ease of use with comprehensive online tools, including provider directories and a straightforward claims process. Their customer support team is known for being helpful, knowledgeable, and highly responsive.
Additional Benefits and Perks:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife includes unique perks like discounts on vision care, hearing aids, prescription eyewear, and access to oral health resources, offering added value beyond basic dental coverage.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian often bundles additional perks into its dental plans, such as access to telehealth consultations, orthodontic discounts, teeth whitening savings, and even coverage for implants on select plans, significantly enhancing overall value.
Reputation and Customer Reviews:
MetLife Dental:
MetLife enjoys strong brand recognition, receiving positive reviews for broad coverage options, an extensive dental network, and consistent reliability. Customers frequently highlight the convenience and quality of their dental care experience.
Guardian Dental:
Guardian Dental consistently earns high customer ratings, praised for comprehensive coverage options, robust additional benefits, and supportive customer service. Clients particularly appreciate Guardian’s straightforward approach to claims and generous annual limits.
Suitability and Recommendations:
Choose MetLife Dental if you prefer extensive provider access, strong brand reliability, easy-to-navigate online tools, and predictable, budget-friendly premiums.
Choose Guardian Dental if you value slightly lower premiums, higher annual benefit limits, generous coverage options (including implants and orthodontics), and attractive bundled perks for overall wellness.
Conclusion:
Both MetLife and Guardian Dental provide attractive, affordable dental insurance plans tailored to meet diverse client needs. Your choice ultimately depends on your personal dental priorities, budget, and specific healthcare goals.
Review the details carefully, consider your expected dental care needs, and confidently choose the provider that aligns best with your financial objectives and healthcare requirements.
Which has better coverage, MetLife Dental or Guardian Dental?
Both offer comprehensive coverage, including preventive, basic, and major dental services. MetLife covers preventive care fully, with good coverage for basic procedures. Guardian provides similar coverage but also includes options for implants and orthodontics, making it slightly broader.
Is MetLife Dental or Guardian Dental more affordable?
Guardian Dental generally offers slightly lower monthly premiums ($20–$55) compared to MetLife ($25–$60). Guardian also typically provides higher annual maximum benefits ($1,000–$3,000), potentially lowering overall costs.
Which provider has a larger dental network?
MetLife Dental has a slightly larger provider network, with over 146,000 participating dentists nationwide, compared to Guardian Dental’s extensive network of around 120,000 dentists.
Are there waiting periods for MetLife Dental and Guardian Dental plans?
Both providers typically apply waiting periods for major dental services, usually ranging from 6 to 12 months. Preventive care is typically covered immediately by both insurers.
Do MetLife Dental and Guardian Dental offer additional perks?
Yes. MetLife provides additional discounts on vision and hearing care. Guardian Dental includes bundled benefits such as telehealth consultations, orthodontic discounts, and teeth whitening savings.
Which insurer offers easier claims processing and customer service?
Both MetLife and Guardian offer user-friendly online tools. Guardian Dental is often praised for especially responsive and supportive customer service, though MetLife is also highly rated.
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent
Expertise: All personal and commercial line insurance, including auto, home, business, health, and life insurance.
License: 16117464