Call or Text

Office visit by appointment Only

Is Progressive Cheaper Than Geico?

Is Progressive Cheaper Than Geico

As an independent insurance agent at Blake Insurance Group, I understand that choosing the right auto insurance provider is a critical decision that can significantly impact your financial security and peace of mind. With the myriad of options available in the market, conducting a thorough comparison is essential to ensure you’re getting the best value for your money. Two of the most prominent names in the auto insurance industry are Progressive and Geico. Both companies are renowned for their competitive rates, comprehensive coverage options, and customer service excellence. However, when it comes down to the question, “Is Progressive cheaper than Geico?” the answer isn’t as straightforward as one might think.

Insurance costs are influenced by many factors, including, but not limited to, your driving history, the type of vehicle you drive, and even your geographical location. Additionally, each insurance provider offers a unique set of discounts, coverage options, and customer service experiences that can affect the overall value you receive. As your trusted insurance advisor, I aim to guide you through the nuances of comparing Progressive and Geico, helping you make an informed decision that aligns with your needs and budget.

The following sections will delve into various subtopics crucial for understanding the differences between Progressive and Geico. From coverage options and discounts to customer service ratings and technology tools, we aim to provide a comprehensive overview that will empower you to choose the insurance provider that best suits your individual requirements. Let’s embark on this journey together, ensuring you’re well-informed and confident in your auto insurance selection.


At Blake Insurance Group, we respect your privacy. Your personal information is used solely for quote purposes and is not shared or sold

Coverage Options and Limits: Progressive vs. Geico

When comparing the standard coverage options offered by Progressive and Geico, it’s essential to understand the foundational elements of auto insurance they both provide. These foundational coverages include liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage, which are critical for protecting drivers financially in case of an accident, theft, or other vehicle damage.

Liability Coverage

Progressive and Geico offer liability coverage, a mandatory requirement in most states. This coverage pays for bodily injury and property damage that the policyholder is responsible for in the event of an accident. Liability coverage is crucial as it covers the costs associated with injuries to other people or damage to their property up to the limits specified in the policy.

Comprehensive and Collision Coverage

Comprehensive and collision coverages are optional and provide broader protection for your vehicle. Comprehensive coverage protects against non-collision-related incidents like theft, vandalism, or natural disasters. Collision coverage, on the other hand, pays for damages to your vehicle resulting from a collision, regardless of who is at fault. Progressive and Geico offer these coverages, allowing policyholders to repair or replace their cars after covered incidents.

Unique Coverage Options

While both insurers provide the standard suite of auto insurance coverages, they also offer unique options that cater to specific needs:

Progressive’s Unique Offerings:

– **Custom Parts and Equipment Coverage**: Progressive covers aftermarket parts and customizations to your vehicle. This coverage particularly appeals to those who have enhanced their cars with custom parts or high-end audio equipment.

– **Ride-Share Insurance**: Progressive offers ride-share insurance for drivers who use their vehicles for ride-sharing services. This coverage fills the gap between personal auto insurance and the coverage provided by ride-sharing companies, offering protection while the app is on but before accepting a ride request.

Geico’s Unique Offerings:

– **Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI)**: Geico offers Mechanical Breakdown Insurance, similar to an extended warranty but often cheaper. MBI covers many mechanical failures after the manufacturer’s warranty expires, excluding wear and tear. This coverage is available for new or leased cars less than 15 months old and less than 15,000 miles.

– **Emergency Road Service**: Geico’s Emergency Road Service is an optional coverage that assists with common roadside issues like flat tires, dead batteries, and lockouts. While many insurers offer similar services, Geico’s version is noted for its affordability and ease of use through the Geico mobile app.

Price Comparison Table for Different Driver Profiles: Progressive vs. Geico

The following table compares average annual rates for different Progressive and Geico driver profiles. These profiles include teens, young adults, adults, seniors, and drivers with a DUI.

Driver Profile Geico Average Annual Rate Progressive Average Annual Rate
Teens $5,048 $8,495
Young Adults (20s) $1,438 $2,287
Adults (30s) $1,218 $2,287
Seniors (65+) $1,197 $1,940
Drivers with a DUI $3,598 $2,810


– **Teens**: Geico offers significantly lower rates for teen drivers than Progressive. Geico’s average teen rate is $5,048, while Progressive’s is $8,495.

– **Young Adults (20s)**: For young adults in their 20s, Geico’s average rate is $1,438, substantially lower than Progressive’s average rate of $2,287.

– **Adults (30s)**: Geico continues to offer more competitive rates for adults in their 30s, with an average rate of $1,218 compared to Progressive’s $2,287.

– **Seniors (65+)**: Geico’s average rate for senior drivers is $1,197, while Progressive’s average rate for this demographic is $1,940, making Geico the cheaper option for seniors.

– **Drivers with a DUI**: Progressive offers a lower average annual rate for drivers with a DUI at $2,810, compared to Geico’s rate of $3,598.

It’s important to note that these rates are averages and can vary based on various factors, including location, vehicle type, driving history, and more. Additionally, the rates provided are for illustrative purposes and may not reflect the current rates. Drivers should obtain personalized quotes from both insurers to determine the most accurate rates for their situation.

Discounts and Savings: Progressive vs. Geico

Progressive and Geico offer discounts to help customers save on auto insurance premiums. These discounts are designed to reward safe driving, encourage customer loyalty, and provide savings for having certain vehicle safety features. Below, we detail the range of discounts available from both insurers and explain how customers can qualify for these discounts and the potential savings they might expect.

Progressive Discounts

Multi-Policy Discount

– **Description**: Customers can save by bundling multiple insurance policies, such as auto and home insurance.

– **Qualification**: Purchase two or more Progressive policies.

– **Potential Savings**: An average of 5% off one of the policy’s premiums.

Safe Driver Discount (Snapshot)

– **Description**: Progressive’s Snapshot program rewards safe driving behavior as monitored through their telematics device.

– **Qualification**: Drive safely while being monitored by Progressive’s Snapshot program.

– **Potential Savings**: An average of $145 when renewing your policy.

Vehicle Safety Discounts

– **Description**: Discounts for vehicles with safety features like anti-lock brakes and airbags.

– **Qualification**: Own a vehicle with qualifying safety features.

– **Potential Savings**: Varies, but customers can receive a discount of up to 23% for having a vehicle with airbags.

Geico Discounts

Multi-Policy Discount

– **Description**: Savings for customers with more than one policy type with Geico, such as auto and homeowners insurance.

– **Qualification**: Insure your car with Geico and have another type of policy with the company, like homeowners or renters insurance.

– **Potential Savings**: The amount saved varies depending on policy selection, state of residence, and other factors.

Safe Driver Discount

– **Description**: Geico rewards accident-free drivers with a discount on their car insurance premiums for five years.

– **Qualification**: No accidents for five years.

– **Potential Savings**: Up to 22% on your car insurance premium.

Vehicle Safety Discounts

– **Description**: Discounts for cars with safety features like airbags, anti-lock brakes, and anti-theft systems.

– **Qualification**: Own a vehicle with qualifying safety features.

– **Potential Savings**: Up to 25% for cars with driver-side airbags and 40% for full-frontal airbags. A 5% discount on the collision portion of the insurance coverage for cars with anti-lock brakes and up to 25% on comprehensive coverage for cars with built-in anti-theft systems.

How to Qualify and Expected Savings

To qualify for these discounts, customers must meet the specific criteria set by each insurer. For instance, to benefit from the safe driver discounts, Progressive customers need to enroll in the Snapshot program and demonstrate safe driving habits. In contrast, Geico customers must maintain a clean driving record for five years. The potential savings from these discounts can significantly reduce the overall cost of insurance premiums, with specific savings depending on the customer’s policy, the state of residence, and other factors.

Progressive and Geico make it relatively straightforward for customers to apply for and receive these discounts. Typically, customers can inquire about eligibility and apply for discounts when obtaining a quote or contacting customer service. It’s also worth noting that the availability of specific discounts may vary by state, and combining multiple discounts can lead to even more significant savings on auto insurance premiums.

Customer Service and Claims Process: Progressive vs. Geico

Customer Service Ratings


– **J.D. Power Scores**: Progressive’s customer satisfaction ratings are mixed. In the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Insurance Study, Progressive received below-average satisfaction ratings in every region. In the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Insurance Shopping Study, Progressive scored 853 out of 1,000 points, below the industry average for large insurers of 861.

– **NAIC Complaint Ratios**: According to the NAIC, Progressive has a slightly higher customer complaint rate than the national median, with a score of 1.41. This indicates a higher number of complaints relative to the company’s size.


– **J.D. Power Scores**: Geico’s customer satisfaction scores also vary. In the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Insurance Shopping Study, Geico scored slightly below average with 857 points. In the 2023 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, Geico scored 871 out of 1,000, below average.

– **NAIC Complaint Ratios**: Geico has a slightly above-average complaint index score with the NAIC, with an index of 1.04, indicating it receives somewhat more complaints than average for an insurer of its size.

Claims Process


– **Claims Filing**: Customers can file claims with Progressive through various channels, including online, by phone, or by mobile app.

– **Claims Resolution**: Progressive policyholders have reported mixed experiences with the claims process. Some customers have praised the helpful customer service agents and quick claims process, while others have expressed frustrations with preferred repair facilities.

– **Customer Satisfaction**: In the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study, Progressive scored 870 out of 1,000, indicating that customers are generally less satisfied with the claims process than other insurers.


– **Claims Filing**: Geico allows customers to file claims through its website, mobile app, or phone. The company is known for its easy claims process, with checks mailed out as quickly as 48 hours after an accident.

– **Claims Resolution**: Geico’s claims process is generally well-regarded, with many positive reviews mentioning speedy resolution and reliable customer service.

– **Customer Satisfaction**: Policyholders rated Geico’s customer satisfaction with the claims process at 4.1 stars out of 5, indicating a relatively high level of satisfaction.

Usage-Based Insurance Programs: Progressive Snapshot vs. Geico DriveEasy

Progressive Snapshot

How It Affects Premiums

Progressive’s Snapshot is a usage-based insurance program that adjusts premiums based on driving behavior. Customers can receive an immediate discount for participating in the program, except in Hawaii and New York. Upon completing the program, the discount or rate adjustment is applied at policy renewal, depending on the driving habits recorded. While most drivers can save money with Snapshot, some may see an increase in their premiums if they exhibit high-risk driving behaviors.

Monitored Driving Behavior

Snapshot tracks various driving behaviors, including:

– Sudden changes in speed, such as rapid acceleration and hard braking.

– The amount and time of day you drive, with late-night driving being considered riskier.

– Mobile phone usage while driving, which is indicative of distracted driving.

– As more miles are driven, overall mileage can increase the likelihood of accidents.

Potential for Discounts or Rate Increases

Customers who demonstrate safe driving habits can earn significant discounts. Progressive reports that drivers who save using Snapshot have an average annual savings of $146. However, approximately 2 out of 10 Snapshot drivers may see increased car insurance costs due to risky driving habits. The program is intended to reward safer drivers with lower rates and align premiums more closely with individual risk levels.

Geico DriveEasy

How It Affects Premiums

Geico’s DriveEasy program offers personalized rates based on driving habits. Customers can receive discounts for safe driving, but unlike some usage-based programs, DriveEasy may also increase rates for poor driving performance. The program is currently available in 37 states and Washington, D.C. The app is telematics-based, meaning it uses real-time driving data to calculate rates.

Monitored Driving Behavior

DriveEasy monitors several driving behaviors, including:

– Speeding and hard braking.

– Cornering and smoothness of driving.

– Handheld phone use can negatively impact the driving score even if a passenger is using the phone.

– Time of day, distance driven, and weather conditions.

Potential for Discounts or Rate Increases

While Geico does not disclose the exact discount for using DriveEasy, safe drivers can expect to save on their premiums. However, risky driving behaviors can lead to higher rates. The program continuously monitors driving, meaning that insurance costs may adjust at each policy renewal based on the most recent driving score. Geico emphasizes that safer driving leads to better scores and more savings, but riskier drivers may see a higher rate depending on their state.