Cigna Medicare vs UnitedHealthcare Medicare
Cigna Medicare vs. UnitedHealthcare Medicare: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Choosing the right Medicare provider is a critical step toward better healthcare in retirement. Cigna and UnitedHealthcare (UHC) are two of the most trusted names offering Medicare Advantage, Part D, and Medigap plans. Here’s how they compare to help you make an informed choice or talk with an independent Medicare agent.
Overview of Each Company
Cigna:
Founded in 1982, headquartered in Bloomfield, CT.
Offers Medicare Advantage, Part D, and Medigap plans in many states.
Focus on holistic health with programs for behavioral, dental, and chronic condition care.
Growing footprint in the Medicare Advantage market.
DISCLAIMERS
“By submitting this form, you agree that a licensed sales representative may contact you about Medicare Advantage, Prescription Drug, and Medicare Supplement Insurance plans.” “This is a solicitation for insurance.”
UnitedHealthcare:
Backed by UnitedHealth Group, the largest health insurance company in the U.S.
Offers the most widely enrolled Medicare Advantage plans nationwide.
Strategic partnership with AARP for branded Medigap policies.
Broad access to healthcare technology and national care networks.
Customer Reviews
Share This
Medicare Plans Offered
| Plan Type | Cigna | UnitedHealthcare |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare Advantage (Part C) | Yes – HMO, PPO | Yes – HMO, PPO, HMO-POS |
| Prescription Drug Plans (Part D) | Yes – 3 tiers typically | Yes – multiple plans, often in partnership with AARP |
| Medicare Supplement (Medigap) | Yes – Plans A, F, G, N (varies by state) | Yes – AARP-branded Plans A-N |
| Special Needs Plans (SNPs) | Yes – for dual-eligibles and chronic illness | Yes – wide availability of SNPs |
Network & Availability
Cigna:
- Expanding Medicare Advantage plans across 29+ states.
- Regional network strength; network sizes vary by state.
- Includes telehealth and chronic care management networks.
UnitedHealthcare:
- Available in all 50 states with expansive national coverage.
- Offers one of the largest provider networks in the country.
- Access to nationwide urgent care, virtual visits, and AARP-endorsed networks.
Verdict: UnitedHealthcare has a broader, more established network nationwide. Cigna has strong regional offerings and is expanding steadily.
Benefits & Extras
| Benefit Type | Cigna | UnitedHealthcare |
|---|---|---|
| Dental, Vision, Hearing | Included in most Advantage plans | Included in most Advantage plans |
| OTC Allowance | Yes – varies by plan | Yes – available in many plans |
| Fitness Programs | Silver&Fit | Renew Active (UHC exclusive) |
| Telehealth | Available | Available, with expanded virtual network |
| Extra Support Programs | Care coordination, chronic care, behavioral health | HouseCalls program, wellness coaching, social support services |
Verdict: Both are robust, but UHC’s Renew Active and HouseCalls give it an edge in proactive wellness support.
Premiums & Out-of-Pocket Costs
Cigna:
Offers $0 premium Medicare Advantage plans in many areas.
Competitive max out-of-pocket limits.
Medigap prices tend to be regionally competitive.
UnitedHealthcare:
Also offers $0 premium Advantage plans with wide availability.
Often offers Part B giveback programs in select areas.
Medigap plans may have higher premiums, but offer more stability and lower out-of-pocket risk.
Verdict: Both providers are competitive in terms of pricing. Cigna may be more cost-effective in some regions, while UHC often provides broader long-term value.
Enrollment & Ease of Use
Cigna:
User-friendly website and mobile app.
Tools to find plans, doctors, and prescriptions easily.
Personalized support through licensed agents.
UnitedHealthcare:
Excellent enrollment tools integrated with AARP and Medicare.gov.
User dashboard with pharmacy integration, digital ID cards.
Highly rated mobile app for managing care.
Verdict: UHC offers more robust digital tools and national support resources. Cigna still provides solid support and ease of enrollment, especially through independent agents.
Who Each Plan Is Ideal For
| Beneficiary Type | Best Pick |
|---|---|
| Looking for nationwide network access | UnitedHealthcare |
| Focused on behavioral and chronic care | Cigna |
| Wanting a $0 premium plan | Both |
| Fitness and wellness enthusiasts | UnitedHealthcare |
| Prefer regional or smaller provider networks | Cigna |
| Tech-savvy users | UnitedHealthcare |
Pros and Cons
Cigna Medicare
Pros:
- Affordable Medicare Advantage options.
- Great for chronic care management.
- Solid behavioral health support and member programs.
Cons:
- Smaller provider network in some regions.
- Not available in all 50 states.
UnitedHealthcare Medicare
Pros:
- Largest Medicare Advantage enrollment in the U.S.
- Wide provider access and pharmacy integration.
- Excellent wellness and support programs.
Cons:
- Medigap plans may be more expensive.
- Some plans have stricter referral or authorization rules.
Final Verdict: Which Medicare Plan Wins?
Both Cigna and UnitedHealthcare are excellent Medicare providers. Your best choice depends on your healthcare needs, geographic location, and preference for network size or extra benefits:
- Choose Cigna if you want strong regional value, chronic care support, and behavioral health resources.
- Choose UnitedHealthcare if you prioritize nationwide access, fitness and wellness extras, or AARP-backed stability.
Need help deciding? An independent Medicare agent can compare both options in your area and help you choose the plan that fits your prescriptions, providers, and budget.
Learn about health insurance options available in Alabama and find the right plan for you.
Read MoreExplore the three types of Special Needs Plans (SNPs) and how they can benefit you.
Read MoreFind affordable individual health insurance plans tailored to residents of Arizona.
Read MoreDiscover comprehensive health insurance plans available for residents of North Carolina.
Read MoreFrequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed
Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent