Got Insurance Through Costco? Here’s Why You Should Compare It with Blake Insurance Group
If you purchased or received a quote for auto or home insurance through Costco, you’re likely enrolled with CONNECT by American Family Insurance, the provider behind Costco’s member-exclusive insurance program. While Costco’s insurance benefits may sound appealing, it’s worth asking:
👉 Is your coverage truly the best fit for your needs, or just a good deal on the surface?
At Blake Insurance Group, we help Costco members like you take a second look at their policy—often uncovering better coverage, more flexible options, and additional savings.
Costco Insurance vs. Blake Insurance Group: What’s the Real Difference?
Feature | Costco Insurance (CONNECT) | Blake Insurance Group |
---|---|---|
Insurance Provider | CONNECT by American Family | Multiple top-rated national and regional insurers |
Quote Process | Online or through CONNECT call center | Personalized, agent-guided quote comparison |
Policy Options | Standardized coverage bundles | Fully customized to fit your lifestyle |
Discount Opportunities | Costco member and multi-policy discounts | Full discount review including bundling, loyalty, safe driver & more |
Customer Support | CONNECT call center (varies in experience) | Dedicated agent support for life of the policy |
Claims Assistance | Through CONNECT | Agent-guided claims help and follow-up |
Policy Flexibility | Limited to CONNECT’s offerings | Access to dozens of insurers and flexible terms |
🔍 Why Costco Insurance Might Not Be Your Best Long-Term Option
While Costco’s insurance program offers exclusive discounts, it has a few key limitations:
You’re tied to just one insurer (CONNECT), meaning fewer choices and less room for customization
Discounts may not stack as well as advertised, especially if you’re not bundling other policies
Policy options are standardized, meaning you may not get coverage tailored to your lifestyle or risks
Support is often handled via large call centers with limited personal touch or claim advocacy
At Blake Insurance Group, we believe you deserve a personal insurance advisor, not just a membership discount.
💡 Already Insured Through Costco? Let Us Review Your Policy—Free
If you’re currently insured with Costco or CONNECT, we offer a free, no-obligation policy review. Our licensed agents will:
✔ Check your policy for coverage gaps or unnecessary add-ons
✔ Compare rates from multiple top insurers
✔ Apply all eligible discounts (many not shown in Costco’s system)
✔ Recommend ways to improve coverage or reduce your premium
✔ Help you switch with no disruption—only if it makes sense for you
🛡️ What You Get with Blake Insurance Group
✅ Access to Dozens of Insurance Companies
We’re not limited to one carrier. We shop the market to find you the best match, whether it’s auto, home, RV, business, or life insurance.
✅ Real Human Guidance
No waiting on hold with a call center. You get a dedicated insurance agent who knows your name and your goals.
✅ More Than Just Auto & Home
Need to insure a boat, motorcycle, business, or high-value home? We’ve got you covered—and we can help you bundle policies for even bigger savings.
✅ Long-Term Support
From policy changes to claims assistance, we’re with you for the life of your policy—not just during sign-up.
🎯 Compare Your Costco Insurance with Blake Insurance Group Today
Even if you’re happy with your Costco insurance, it never hurts to see if you’re missing out on better value. At Blake Insurance Group, we’re here to:
Uncover better coverage
Maximize your discounts
Advocate for you when it matters most
📞 Call us today or click below for a Free, No-Obligation Quote Review
👉
✨ Don’t Settle for Cookie-Cutter Coverage—Customize It with Blake Insurance Group
Costco is great for bulk savings—insurance? Not always.
Let us help you find coverage that truly fits your life, not just your membership.
Related Insurance Calculators
✔ Bundling home + auto
✔ Safe driver discounts
✔ Loyalty, low mileage, defensive driving, and more
- Auto & Homeowners
- Renters & Condo
- Life & Health
- RV, Motorcycle, and Boat
- Business & Commercial
Blake Insurance Group: You get a dedicated local agent who will assist you with quotes, changes, and even claims—for the life of your policy.

Blake Nwosu
Owner & Principal Agent
Expertise: All personal and commercial line insurance, including auto, home, business, health, and life insurance.
License: 16117464
Blake Insurance Group
Phone: (888) 387-3687
Email: info@blakeinsurancegroup.com
Hours: Mon-Fri 9:00 am to 5:00 pm
Sat-Sun: Closed