Business insurance • Company comparisons
Small Business Insurance Companies Compared: Insurers, MGAs, and Brokers (2026)
Small business insurance brands aren’t all the same kind of company. Some are insurers that issue and pay claims on their own policies, some are underwriters that place policies with partner carriers, and some are agencies or brokers that shop several insurers for you. Knowing which is which tells you who stands behind your coverage and who handles your claim.
This hub groups the 17 companies we have reviewed by type, with the issuing insurer, rating, and how you buy, plus links to 45 head-to-head comparisons and our state guides. We don’t rank companies; the right fit depends on your business. Blake Insurance Group is an independent agency, and mentioning a company here doesn’t mean we represent it.
Compare small business insurance quotes
Tell us your business type, revenue, payroll, and the coverage your contracts require, and a licensed agent will follow up with quotes from the insurers we offer in your state. Submitting the form does not bind coverage.
If the form does not load, call 888-387-3687, Monday through Friday, 9:00 to 5:00, or email admin@blakeinsurancegroup.com.
Blake Insurance Group LLC is an independent insurance agency. Licensed insurance producer NPN 16117464.
Prefer to quote online yourself?
Start a business insurance quote online with one of our partners, without waiting for a call back.
Get a quote from ERGO NEXT →General liability, workers’ compensation, business owner’s policies, professional liability, and commercial auto.
Start an application with First Connect →Quotes from multiple insurance carriers through our First Connect portal.
Sponsored. Each link opens the partner’s website in a new tab, where its terms and privacy policy apply. Blake Insurance Group may be compensated if you buy.
Insurers that issue their own policies
| Company | Type | Rating | How you buy | Often a fit for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Hartford | Insurer | AM Best A+ (Superior) | Online, by phone, or through agents | Established insurer with a broad small business lineup |
| Hiscox | Insurer | AM Best A (Excellent) | Online, by phone, or through agents and brokers | Professional liability and small professional firms |
| biBerk | Insurer (Berkshire Hathaway) | A++ for key subsidiaries, per biBerk | Online or by phone, no agents | Direct buyers who want workers’ comp or a BOP online |
| ERGO NEXT | Insurer (Munich Re’s ERGO) | AM Best A+ (Superior), since Sept. 2025 | Online and through agents | Fast online quotes and instant certificates |
| Pie Insurance | Insurer (workers’ comp focus) | AM Best A- (Excellent) | Online and through partner agencies | Workers’ comp with pay-as-you-go billing |
| Coalition | Cyber insurer and broker | Coalition Insurance Company: AM Best A- (Excellent) | Through brokers only | Cyber coverage with security monitoring |
| Corgi | Insurance group with its own carriers | Risk retention group not rated by AM Best | Online quote or demo | Venture-backed startups |
Ratings and ownership as described in each review, checked October and November 2026. Ratings change; confirm with AM Best before you buy.
Underwriters and MGAs
| Company | Type | Issuing carriers | How you buy | Often a fit for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Foxquilt | Managing general underwriter | Markel and other partners | Online or through agents | Contractors and micro businesses |
| Slice | MGA | Philadelphia Insurance Companies (AM Best A++) | Through agents only | Contractors general liability |
| Thimble | Agency owned by Arch | Markel, National Specialty, and other partners | Online or app | Coverage by the job, month, or year |
With an MGA, the carrier named on your policy is the company that pays claims, so check its rating.
Agencies, brokers, and marketplaces
| Company | Type | How you buy |
|---|---|---|
| Simply Business | Online broker and marketplace (Travelers-owned) | Compare quotes from its carrier panel |
| CoverWallet | Aon’s digital insurance agency | Online with agent support |
| Coverdash | Digital and embedded agency, 40+ carriers | Online or inside partner apps |
| Attune | Agent platform, an EverPeak company | Through your agent only |
| Vouch | Broker for startups (underwriting sold to Hiscox) | Online application plus a broker team |
| Newfront | Brokerage, part of WTW | Through an advisor |
| Founder Shield | Broker, now The Baldwin Group Innovation Practice | Online application plus a broker |
These companies don’t issue policies; your claim goes to the insurer named on the policy they place.
How to choose a small business insurance company
- Start with your contracts. List the coverage, limits, additional insured, and waiver requirements you must meet.
- Match the company to your risk. Startups often need D&O and cyber; contractors need general liability, workers’ comp, and tools coverage; professionals need E&O.
- Check who issues the policy and its AM Best rating, not just the brand.
- Compare the same coverage on every quote: limits, deductibles, exclusions, and endorsements.
- Ask how claims are reported and whether you get a person or an online form.
Head-to-head comparisons
Vouch comparisons
- Vouch vs. Simply Business
- Vouch vs. The Hartford
- Vouch vs. Hiscox
- Vouch vs. CoverWallet
- Vouch vs. Coalition
- Vouch vs. Newfront
- Vouch vs. ERGO NEXT
- Vouch vs. Embroker
- Vouch vs. Corgi
- Vouch vs. Insureon
- Vouch vs. Coterie
- Vouch vs. Thimble
- Vouch vs. Founder Shield
ERGO NEXT comparisons
- ERGO NEXT vs. Vouch
- ERGO NEXT vs. Foxquilt
- ERGO NEXT vs. Attune
- ERGO NEXT vs. Simply Business
- ERGO NEXT vs. Pie Insurance
- ERGO NEXT vs. Embroker
- ERGO NEXT vs. Progressive Commercial
- ERGO NEXT vs. Coverdash
- ERGO NEXT vs. Thimble
- ERGO NEXT vs. biBerk
- ERGO NEXT vs. Hiscox
- ERGO NEXT vs. Hiscox vs. Thimble
Coterie comparisons
- Coterie vs. Vouch
- Coterie vs. Simply Business
- Coterie vs. Foxquilt
- Coterie vs. Pie Insurance
- Coterie vs. Embroker
- Coterie vs. Attune
- Coterie vs. Coverdash
- Coterie vs. Thimble
- Coterie vs. biBerk
- Coterie vs. Thimble vs. Coverdash
- Coterie vs. biBerk vs. Hiscox
- Coterie vs. Hiscox
- Coterie vs. ERGO NEXT
Other comparisons
Small business insurance companies by state
Small business insurance company FAQs
What is the best small business insurance company?
It depends on your business. Compare insurers on the coverage you need, the issuing company’s AM Best rating, price, and how claims are handled.
What is the difference between an insurer, an MGA, and a broker?
An insurer issues the policy and pays claims, an MGA underwrites on behalf of partner insurers, and a broker or agency shops policies from several insurers for you.
How do I check if a small business insurer is financially strong?
Look up the issuing insurer’s AM Best financial strength rating, which can differ from the brand you buy through.
Can an independent agent compare these companies for me?
An independent agency can compare quotes from the insurers it is appointed with in your state.
Related guides
Important information
Compensation. Links in the partner quote box near the top of this page are sponsored, and Blake Insurance Group may be paid if you make a purchase. Sponsored placement does not affect the other information on this page.
Independent agency. Blake Insurance Group LLC is an independent insurance agency. Licensed insurance producer NPN 16944666. Licensed states: AZ, AL, TX, CA, NY, OH, FL, NC, VA, GA, OK, NM, IA, KS, MI, NE, SC, SD, WV, IL, NJ, PA, TN, and WA. Which insurance companies we can quote depends on our current appointments, the product, and your state. Mentioning a company on this page does not mean we represent it.
Cost figures. Published averages and ranges are cited from the sources named, as of the dates shown. They are not quotes and may not reflect your price, which depends on the insurer, your state, your business, your payroll and revenue, your limits, and your claims history.
Availability. Coverage, prices, discounts, and eligibility vary by insurer, state, and applicant, and are subject to underwriting. The issued policy controls.
Your next step
Tell us about your business, and a licensed agent will compare quotes from the insurers we offer in your state.